Skip to content Instant Roofer Logo INSTANT ROOFER
Contractor Sign Up

Butler Roof Replacement Costs

GET INSTANT ESTIMATES

Free. No obligation. No credit card required.

The average cost to replace a roof in Butler, Pennsylvania is $12,505.

Enter your address into our roofing calculator, select the roofing material and instantly view estimates from top-rated contractors in Butler.

Instant Roofer Guarantee Badge
Roof Measure Icon
Measure

27,583 Roofs measured by our roofing calculator in Butler, PA

Roof Estimate Icon
Estimate

$12,505 Average roof replacement cost for Asphalt Shingle roofs in Butler, PA

Roofer Connect Icon
Connect

13 Highly rated roofers in Butler, PA

All stats on this page are based on data roofing contractors have entered into the Instant Roofer Database. Data is refreshed weekly.

Roof Replacement Cost in Butler, Pennsylvania

The average cost to replace a roof in Butler is about $12,505. This is based on the average roof size (with pitch) in Butler of 1,950 sqft (19.67 squares) and the area’s most common material, Asphalt Shingle, which run about $6.41 per sqft ($641/square).

Average Cost by Material

Roof replacement cost can vary greatly depending on the type of roofing material used. The costs listed below are based on a 1,950 sqft roof (19.67 squares) in Butler.

Costs calculated from data entered by roofing contractors into the Instant Roofer Database. Data is refreshed weekly.

Roof Replacement Costs by Home Size

Home size is one of the biggest factors contributing to replacement costs. This table shows replacement costs for different home sizes for each roofing material in Butler.

Asphalt Shingle
$6.41/sqft ($641/square)
SQFTSQUARESCOST
5005$3,206
1,00010$6,413
1,50015$9,619
2,00020$12,826
2,50025$16,032
3,00030$19,238
3,50035$22,445
4,00040$25,651
4,50045$28,858
5,00050$32,064
Designer Shingle
$9.40/sqft ($940/square)
SQFTSQUARESCOST
5005$4,702
1,00010$9,404
1,50015$14,107
2,00020$18,809
2,50025$23,511
3,00030$28,213
3,50035$32,916
4,00040$37,618
4,50045$42,320
5,00050$47,022
Slate
$22.69/sqft ($2,269/square)
SQFTSQUARESCOST
5005$11,345
1,00010$22,690
1,50015$34,035
2,00020$45,380
2,50025$56,725
3,00030$68,070
3,50035$79,415
4,00040$90,760
4,50045$102,105
5,00050$113,450
Costs calculated from data entered by roofing contractors into the Instant Roofer Database. Data is refreshed weekly.

How Roof Replacement Impacts Home Value

Homeowners frequently want to know how replacing their roof could impact the overall value of their home. This table shows how roof replacement, by material and home size, could impact the value of an Butler home.

Asphalt Shingle
$6.41/sqft ($641/square)
SQFTVALUE ADDED
500$1,924
1,000$3,848
1,500$5,772
2,000$7,695
2,500$9,619
3,000$11,543
3,500$13,467
4,000$15,391
4,500$17,315
5,000$19,238
Designer Shingle
$9.40/sqft ($940/square)
SQFTVALUE ADDED
500$2,868
1,000$5,737
1,500$8,605
2,000$11,473
2,500$14,342
3,000$17,210
3,500$20,079
4,000$22,947
4,500$25,815
5,000$28,684
Slate
$22.69/sqft ($2,269/square)
SQFTVALUE ADDED
500$6,353
1,000$12,706
1,500$19,060
2,000$25,413
2,500$31,766
3,000$38,119
3,500$44,472
4,000$50,826
4,500$57,179
5,000$63,532
Costs calculated from data entered by roofing contractors into the Instant Roofer Database. Data is refreshed weekly.

Butler Roof Statistics

The number of roofs our tech has scanned27,583
Average roof size (with pitch)1,950 Square Feet
Average roof slope4/12 Pitch or 18.43 Degrees
Most common roof typeAsphalt Shingle
Calculated by our AI roofing tech and populated from the Instant Roofer Database. Data is refreshed weekly.

Frequently Asked Roofing Questions In Butler, Pennsylvania

Labor Costs

How much does roofing labor cost in Butler, Pennsylvania compared to nearby areas? In Butler, PA roofing labor usually costs $2.00‑$4.00 per square foot roughly $40‑$65 per hour. That’s a bit cheaper than the Pittsburgh metro area, where rates often land between $2.50 and $4.50 per foot yet still a touch higher than the neighboring rural counties, thanks, to an older housing stock and commuter‑driven demand.

Weather & Climate Considerations

How does Butler, Pennsylvania's weather affect roof lifespan? In Butler, Pennsylvania the climate delivers 40 inches of rain each year about 45‑50 inches of snow average winds hovering, between 9 and 11 mph and close to 2,000 sunshine hours annually. That blend of moisture and repeated freeze‑thaw cycles speeds up shingle wear and encourages ice‑dam formation while the combined weight of snow and gusty breezes strains gutters and flashings and continual UV exposure erodes the roofing material, all of which can markedly shorten a roof’s lifespan without regular upkeep.
What is the most common cause of roof damage in Butler, Pennsylvania? In Butler, Pennsylvania winter is the offender when it comes to roof damage, ice dams and a heavy blanket of snow pile up stressing the roof prying up shingles and eventually letting leaks slip in especially in older homes that lack proper ventilation.
What is the best time of year to replace a roof in Butler, Pennsylvania? Roof replacements, in Butler, Pennsylvania are best tackled from May through September with June and September standing out as the most favorable windows. The areas humid‑continental climate delivers rain‑soaked springs, snow‑laden winters and summer thunderstorms making it wise to sidestep freeze‑thaw intervals and the height of storm activity. Ideally daytime temperatures should stay above 40, 50 °F ensuring proper shingle adhesion and enabling quicker safer work.

Insurance & Storms

How common are storm-related roof claims in Butler, Pennsylvania? Storm‑related roof damage claims are fairly routine in Butler, Pennsylvania in the wake of spring‑summer thunderstorms and the occasional winter gusts. The older tree‑lined districts that cling to the foothills of the Appalachians frequently endure hail, strong winds and broken branches prompting insurers to see a noticeable uptick, in filings after a major storm.
What natural disasters in Butler, Pennsylvania cause the most roof replacements? Roof replacements in Butler, Pennsylvania typically follow summer thunderstorms that dump large hail and generate straight‑line winds; occasional tornadoes, heavy lake‑effect snow and ice loads can also make a new roof necessary and the remnants of Hurricane Ida, in 2021 produced notable wind‑driven roof damage across Butler County.

Top Roofing Contractors in Butler, Pennsylvania

TrinkleyRoofing

5

2 reviews

312 Liberty Street
Butler, PA 16001

(724) 831-0272

Dennis John Home Improvements

5

76 reviews

512 Virginia Avenue
Butler, PA 16001

(724) 487-4245

Matthews Home Improvement

4.2

6 reviews

101 Orchard Avenue
Butler, PA 16001

(724) 614-3628

Neff Gary L Roofing & Contracting

3.9

11 reviews

114 Beblo Lane
Butler, PA 16002

(724) 287-6635

Pa Roof Restoration and Construction

4

4 reviews

12 Vogleyville Road
Butler, PA 16002

(724) 730-1527

Show 8 More

Interstate Builders

4.3

6 reviews

154 Kittanning Street
Butler, PA 16001

(724) 287-3999

Mccormick Roofing

3

2 reviews

102 McCalip Farm Lane
Butler, PA 16002

(724) 504-2868

Ryan Zillweger Contracting, Inc

5

3 reviews

100 Zillweger Ln
Butler, PA 16002

(724) 443-0413

Quality Roof Installation

5

1 review

215 Birchwood Drive
Butler, PA 16001

(724) 234-8862

Birckbichler Construction

4

4 reviews

455 Chicora Road
Butler, PA 16001

(724) 332-5088

Ziaciks All-Pro Exteriors

5

1 review

262 Great Belt Road
Butler, PA 16002

(724) 480-6583

Cancilla Brothers Inc

5

2 reviews

2478 William Flynn Highway
Butler, PA 16001

(724) 282-3443

J Scott Roofing

5

1 review

523 Hall Road
Butler, PA 16001

(724) 637-2459

Map of Roofing Contractors in Butler, Pennsylvania

Butler Roof Costs Compared to Other Pennsylvania Cities

Pittsburgh, PA

  • $3,525 less expensive
  • Avg Cost: $8,980

Philadelphia, PA

  • $284 less expensive
  • Avg Cost: $12,221

Erie, PA

  • About the same
  • Avg Cost: $12,505

York, PA

  • About the same
  • Avg Cost: $12,505

Reading, PA

  • About the same
  • Avg Cost: $12,505
Relative costs calculated from data entered by roofing contractors into the Instant Roofer Database. Data is refreshed weekly.