Thinking about getting a new roof or replacing your old one? You’re in for quite a ride! When it comes to protecting your home, the material you choose makes the biggest difference. However, with so many options, how can you determine which one is the right fit for you?
We’ve created a roofing materials cost comparison to help you make a better decision. After all, the kind of roof you decide to go for not only contributes to your home’s aesthetic appeal, but also its long-term value.
How do you choose the material for your roof?
Nowadays, getting a roof is in some ways trickier than in the years before. With new materials emerging, it’s easy to get overwhelmed with the options available. Moreover, finding the ideal roofing material is not a ‘one-size-fits-all’ solution.
Every home has its own unique set of demands, based on its location, architectural design, climate, and, of course, its budget. Balancing all these elements can feel quite tricky, but it’s critical for making the best choice for your household.
Roofing materials cost comparison: The most common types of roofing
Asphalt shingles
For years, asphalt shingles have been a top choice for American homeowners. What makes this roofing material such a popular pick is its attractive price, color variety, durability, and relatively easy maintenance.
Nowadays, asphalt shingles come in several options. Homeowners can choose between three-tab style and architectural style, or Energy Star-rated shingles, which offer better energy efficiency.
The downside of this roofing material is its longevity. Compared to metal or tile roofs, they have a much shorter lifespan. Depending on the type of shingles you choose, this kind of roof will last you 15 to 20 years (or 30 years, if you opt for a more premium material).
So, how much does an asphalt roof cost? According to our data, you should expect to pay between $5,000 and $25,000 for your asphalt shingle roof replacement. The nationwide average is around $3.75 to $6.75 per square foot.
Tiles
One of the most aesthetically pleasing roofing options is clay tiles. Often used in Mediterranean and Southwestern-style homes, this roofing material is a great option for those who don’t want to compromise on looks or durability. In fact, countless archaeological sites around the world are a great example of just how long-lived clay products really are (with proper care and maintenance, clay tiles can last between 50 and 100 years).
Another advantage of clay tiles is their ability to insulate buildings effectively. If you decide to opt for this type of roofing, it will be easier to maintain a cool temperature in your home during the summer and keep it warm in winter.
Today, clay can be used to create tiles in a wide range of colors, shapes, and sizes – not just the typical terracotta style most people recognize.
However, if you’re considering a clay roof, you should be prepared for a significantly larger investment. The average cost depends on factors such as your roof’s size, installation costs, and more. However, in general, you can expect to pay between $9 and $15 per square foot.
Metal
Once used only for commercial buildings and barns, metal roofing has now become a popular, stylish choice for residential homes as well. If you’re looking for a clean, modern aesthetic, combined with incredible durability, this may be your best bet!
Similar to asphalt shingles, metal roofing comes in many options. Homeowners can choose between aluminum (an excellent option for coastal areas), steel, and more expensive solutions, such as zinc and copper. Depending on the roof you decide to go for, it will last you 40-70 years or more.
What makes metal roofing such an excellent choice is its ability to significantly improve a home’s energy efficiency. In fact, it can reduce your cooling costs by a quarter! While metal roofs clearly have their advantages, it’s essential to note that they are also quite expensive. The price for this kind of roofing ranges from $8,000 to $80,000, depending on the metal type, roof size, slope, and other factors.
Recap: Roofing materials cost comparison
When the time for a roof replacement comes, the first question that pops into most homeowners’ minds is, ‘How much is it going to cost me?‘ Unfortunately, it’s impossible to give one answer, because it depends on a number of different factors, most notably the choice of material.
In today’s world, we’re spoiled for choice, and that is also true for roofing materials. When deciding between asphalt vs. metal, vs. tile roof, you should think about your priorities. Do you want a roof that lasts as long as possible? Is it important for you to find the most budget-friendly options? Perhaps you’re more focused on the aesthetics? Answering these questions will help you identify the options that best fit your unique needs.
Likewise, you can take advantage of our asphalt and metal roofing calculator, which lets you compare the costs of different roofing materials and, therefore, find the top solution for your budget.
Fact Checked by Lita Legzdina on 09/10/2025